Mission Impossible
Written by Ella Donoghue

Mia and Andrew broke up this past May. Eight short weeks earlier, they had made things official. But a big, blow-out fight over several complications caused them to break up on move-out day, when they promptly fled the scene, heading home to different states for the summer. At the time, it seemed that this outcome was likely for the best: His friends didn’t like her, her family didn’t like him, and they would’ve never survived the distance.
Although Mia swore that she loved him deeply despite it all—she bargained with the “right person, wrong time” belief all summer—she couldn’t ignore the noise from all the people on the outside. The only arrangement that ever proved successful for the pair was simply hanging out and hooking up, which they sustained for four months. The very moment they tried getting serious, it became clear that they never should have. It just didn’t work.
They returned to college in August—after spending the summer apart with no contact—to discover that their on-campus jobs would have them working very closely together this year. It might’ve seemed problematic, but they’d always gotten along. Only now, they had no choice but to get along all of the time. An unlikely friendship began to grow from the forced proximity.
Quickly, Mia and Andrew remembered why they’d liked each other so much. They worked so well together that they almost forgot all their original problems, all the forces that drew them apart just four months prior. Tension was at an all-time high one night in September when Mia was telling a story to Andrew over a chocolate Frosty, and he leaned in and kissed her. It might’ve been a bad idea, but Mia didn’t care. Someone she loved—with whom she had undeniable chemistry—was kissing her. She couldn’t help but kiss him back.
Consider the old flame rekindled.
After three awkward, silence-filled days, they finally talked about the kiss and what it meant. They would have to proceed with the utmost caution: Neither one felt ready to jump back into the relationship that had ended so abruptly. They agreed that being single during their senior year felt right. And it hadn’t worked before, so why would it work now? Maybe it was best to just be friends.
“But what if we just hook up and we’re still friends?” Andrew asked with trepidation. “Let’s just keep being the friends that we are, working together, hanging out, sending each other Instagram Reels, all of it—but also be hooking up. We might be together one day, we might not. But why shouldn’t we kiss in the meantime?”
It was a compelling proposal. Mia obliged.
“It’s just fun,” she said. “We act like we’re dating but we both know that we’re not—I know that I can go on a date with somebody else, or he can, and I wouldn’t care. He’s like my best friend, just, like, with benefits.”
And there it was. Mission Impossible: Goodbye, exes with unfinished business, and hello, friends with benefits. What could possibly go wrong?
When Mia talks about the situation she’s in, she’ll say that it’s purely good vibes. They’re having fun without having to consider what anyone else would have to say about it. They spend time at work together, they share chocolate Frostys, she takes him line dancing with her friends on the weekends, he performs exceptionally well in bed, and the greatest benefit of all: Mia and Andrew are on the same page. There’s no more pressure to figure things out, no more of those old complications. At least presently, this is precisely what they both want and need.
But then, there had to be something Mia was afraid of. So I asked her point blank.
“It scares me because what happens if this doesn’t work out, and we go back to arguing, and then him leaving is just another breakup without the dating?”
Superficially, the arrangement is low-stakes, lighthearted, and easy fun. But just beneath the simple, sexy, non-monogamous surface lie layers of complication that must remain untouched to maintain the sexiness, simplicity, and fun. “We talk about the future and then we’re both like, okay, let’s shut up now. Probably because it becomes too real,” she admitted.
“We both want something real, but I’m not going to fuck around with the label—hard launch it and make him my boyfriend—if it’s just not going to work out. I truly wouldn’t date someone if I had no intention of marrying them, and he feels the same way. Because it crashed and burned last time, there’s always a fear that this time it will crash.”
So they’ve regrouped. They’ve eliminated all the conditions that caused the first crash, and continue making their best efforts to prevent reopening their freshly healed wounds—well, all their best efforts except abstinence. They strive to find a way to be together without spending too much time harping on what will happen in the future—an issue that largely contributed to their relationship’s harrowing end—because “we don’t even know if there will be a future for us,” Mia said. “For now, we just want to enjoy what we are doing because it should be fun—and it is fun.”
How long will they keep this up? Who’s to say. It’s impossible to be friends with benefits forever, and Mia and Andrew are no exception. But I don’t think they want to be. It seems they’re mutually content to watch the future unfold without trying to predict or plan for it. It might be Mission Impossible (1996), but right now, it’s the first half of Friends with Benefits (2011). As long as they’re having fun, they’re game. I’ve advised Mia to get every ounce of enjoyment out of this man with the magic tongue for as long as she sees fit. And I’ve Always Said That.
